This is going to sound weird....

[abelladonna]

But Google has failed me. Or, more accurately, I've failed using Google

Comments

[omphale23]

Could be this, although there's not really any detail (scroll about halfway down the page; is this where you started from?)

http://www.angelfire.com/theforce/haunted/hauntedplacesofindiana.htm

Although the only credible similar story I found was in Illinois (gym balcony collapsed, with a stack of injuries: http://www3.gendisasters.com/illinois/11391/galesville-il-high-school-gym-balcony-collapse-jan-1929)

[abelladonna]

Yep, that's the site that one of the idiots I live with stumbled across online. We actually wanted to know if the old Union Station was haunted, hence the Google-ing. I found that same story repeated here: http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/761007/a_haunted_tour_of_indianapolis_indiana.html?cat=54 But there is no more information. The whole thing has the distinct odor of bullshit, I just didn't know if I was missing something. ;-)

Thanks for the help!