Why is it that some wizards see anything and everything as lesser than them? Others are just as sentient, some are even wiser. And yet they're seen as lesser
( Read more... )
no idea where I was going with this yayshabby_marauderOctober 9 2010, 02:58:36 UTC
Well, speaking from the--ah--proof that I have a first-hand experience of, many of the half-breeds or non-humans have not exactly given themselves a decent name. While I cannot say how much of it is precisely because of the problem you point out, and how much of it is just their nature, but the wizards have been able to keep such control because they keep people safe.
Now, from my own personal stand point, Sirius' opinion (though I think you'll only get a grunt and a frown as an answer), these have and WILL cause me great difficulties, and I'm certain I'll become immune to the sting after awhile. While we are both half-bloods, we approach the wizarding world with a different outlook than the rest of the wizards. Your muggle heritage and my own circumstances have caused us to be on the outskirts, but I can promise you this: some of us belong here. And by us, I'm referring strictly to my own part of the divide. I do truly believe and hope that muggle-borns or half-bloods such as yourself will be able to overcome any hindrances.
Somewhere awesome. <3a_bookish_witchOctober 9 2010, 03:10:53 UTC
I've seen many act in unbecoming ways, but mostly because of provocation. Some that act more permanently that way probably can point to harm done in the past that have become prejudices in the present day -- such as have been discussed throughout the History of Magic classes we take.
True, provocation does play a big part of it. Half-breeds, in particular, are subject to that and consequent displays of aggression. But also, as discussed through our History of Magic classes, some of them are just naturally inclined to aggression--against their own kind of goblins are any point of reference to take seriously.
And. Er. Yes. Delicate situation as I have, I can't let myself be disappointed each time a conflict arises because of it. I would get even more nowhere (a statement which made more sense in my head)
This is my third attempt at replying. Aargh.a_bookish_witchOctober 9 2010, 03:45:11 UTC
Giants are known for being agressive, even amongst themselves. I've had a full giant treat me with respect, when I treated him the same way. It's fully possible.
You shouldn't be nowhere, let alone going further in that direction. This is exactly why we should be assertive.
It's a very rare person who can say something like that. Opportunities like that are what the wizarding world needs, but it will be hard to get things like that set up without making a spectacle of the half-/full-breed.
(long pause) You are a very lucky young witch. You'll go very far with that selfless determination of yours. (small smile)
That's the problem indeed. It's gone so far that it's hard. I'd like to think that I'll always be willing to give the benifit of the doubt, though, until it's proven that this particular creature or person (and even then, more the individual than the race) cannot be trusted or dealt peacefully with.
I... hope so. But I can't do it alone. And luck alone can't do anything.
It is a difficult sort of trial and error. For some creatures and races, it has been far too long that they have been treated in the same way that they are not willing to just overlook it with a bit of respect. In fact, it just might make it worse as they think that you are being mocking by acting like that to them now.
Of course you're not alone. You've got Ron and Harry to support you, do you not? And I'm sure with just a word the entire Gryffindor House will be more than willing to back you. We are brothers and sisters in this House, and lend aid where aid is needed. So don't ever think that you are alone--it's a horrible thought.
It depends on how you approach, and also the exact individual. For example, it would be foolhardy to try and discuss werefolf rights with Fenrir Greyback.
I wish it were that simple. Ron and Harry are reluctant at best, when it comes to my S.P.E.W. endeavors. I've tried campaigning, but not with much success.
Aha Yeah, tell me about it. You get on his bad side and... well.. you might not be the one to suffer, but he'll certainly make his point on someone...
S.P.E.W. got it's beginnings on the house-elf front, did it not? It is hard to feel like you're making any progress with them because they are quite content to serve--quite unlike the Muggle history with slavery, might I add. But the campaign process is a long and slow one. It will work out for the best, I am sure.
But certainly, that doesn't ring true for all werewolves. One cannot base an opinion on all werewolves on him. And yet many do, because he suits their purpose.
True, but they've also been abused in their indenture. And does any beast or being deserve abuse, no matter what their status?
No, it doesn't. At least not while in human form. He only proves what can happen if we let the beast in side of us take over and affect our daily lives. He has embraced it, and has become powerful. I yet still fight it, and well... At least I can stay in school. That is more than enough for me right now, and more of a chance than many others have been given or can be given.
Ah--well, no, no it doesn't... But I'm afraid I've become as immune to it after being brought up in a wizarding household. I can see how coming in from a muggle mindset would certainly see it as such.
You're not the only one, Remus. There's a book, you know. Though written anonymously, he didn't want his secret out, either. But what it says is true. You have a human heart and soul, even if you do transform. You shouldn't be expected to be a beast.
I've been shown that they like working, but really... to feel that they have to punish themselves for doing anything against their master, even if it's for the better good? It's insane!
Just.. hearing that has made me unbelievably happy. Even if I know people do accept me as being a half-breed, I'm always insecure on how they feel about it. Hearing it just reassures me in a way beyond words.
Yes, that is true. I don't know how that custom originated. Like if it is something they did on their own, or if it was forced upon them as a symbol of their servitude.
I'll point out, technically you're fully two things, not half-any. ...you know, it acutally bothers me more that this makes you as happy as you say it does. It shouldn't need to.
I wish I was able to share the same mind-set, but I've been labeled far too long as a half-breed. I'm not completely wolf, but I can't really be considered completely human and so I'm shunted into that half category.
I always like to hear reassurances. I am always so paranoid about what I am that after awhile, I begin to just think negatively about my status. So much so that I begin to forget that people--even my close friends--can overlook it.
I should hardly think that they don't like it. It's clearly very very painful. It doesn't seem to be in the same category as those Muggle priests that used self flagellation as penance...
I think you can be considered completely human, Remus. If someone has any non-magical type of disease, no matter how chronic or uncureable, they're still human so long as they're alive.
Wouldn't the negativity be what causes you to be paranoid? You are who you are, Remus. Status shouldn't matter.
Now, from my own personal stand point, Sirius' opinion (though I think you'll only get a grunt and a frown as an answer), these have and WILL cause me great difficulties, and I'm certain I'll become immune to the sting after awhile. While we are both half-bloods, we approach the wizarding world with a different outlook than the rest of the wizards. Your muggle heritage and my own circumstances have caused us to be on the outskirts, but I can promise you this: some of us belong here. And by us, I'm referring strictly to my own part of the divide. I do truly believe and hope that muggle-borns or half-bloods such as yourself will be able to overcome any hindrances.
I ( ... )
Reply
I'm sorry, immune to the sting?
Reply
And. Er. Yes. Delicate situation as I have, I can't let myself be disappointed each time a conflict arises because of it. I would get even more nowhere (a statement which made more sense in my head)
Reply
You shouldn't be nowhere, let alone going further in that direction. This is exactly why we should be assertive.
Reply
(long pause) You are a very lucky young witch. You'll go very far with that selfless determination of yours. (small smile)
Reply
I'd like to think that I'll always be willing to give the benifit of the doubt, though, until it's proven that this particular creature or person (and even then, more the individual than the race) cannot be trusted or dealt peacefully with.
I... hope so. But I can't do it alone. And luck alone can't do anything.
Reply
Of course you're not alone. You've got Ron and Harry to support you, do you not? And I'm sure with just a word the entire Gryffindor House will be more than willing to back you. We are brothers and sisters in this House, and lend aid where aid is needed. So don't ever think that you are alone--it's a horrible thought.
Reply
I wish it were that simple. Ron and Harry are reluctant at best, when it comes to my S.P.E.W. endeavors. I've tried campaigning, but not with much success.
Reply
S.P.E.W. got it's beginnings on the house-elf front, did it not? It is hard to feel like you're making any progress with them because they are quite content to serve--quite unlike the Muggle history with slavery, might I add. But the campaign process is a long and slow one. It will work out for the best, I am sure.
Reply
True, but they've also been abused in their indenture. And does any beast or being deserve abuse, no matter what their status?
Reply
Ah--well, no, no it doesn't... But I'm afraid I've become as immune to it after being brought up in a wizarding household. I can see how coming in from a muggle mindset would certainly see it as such.
Reply
I've been shown that they like working, but really... to feel that they have to punish themselves for doing anything against their master, even if it's for the better good? It's insane!
Reply
Yes, that is true. I don't know how that custom originated. Like if it is something they did on their own, or if it was forced upon them as a symbol of their servitude.
Reply
...you know, it acutally bothers me more that this makes you as happy as you say it does. It shouldn't need to.
Well, I hardly think they like it!
Reply
I always like to hear reassurances. I am always so paranoid about what I am that after awhile, I begin to just think negatively about my status. So much so that I begin to forget that people--even my close friends--can overlook it.
I should hardly think that they don't like it. It's clearly very very painful. It doesn't seem to be in the same category as those Muggle priests that used self flagellation as penance...
Reply
Wouldn't the negativity be what causes you to be paranoid?
You are who you are, Remus. Status shouldn't matter.
Then it shouldn't be allowed, I think.
Reply
Leave a comment