Leave a comment

wheatear November 25 2013, 22:01:31 UTC
Ah well. I 100% disagree with this. I thought the ending was great and entirely respectful to what came before.

Reply

_thirty2flavors November 25 2013, 23:17:44 UTC
I mean, Steven Moffat gave an interview later and said "well the Doctor would NEVER have ended the Time War so OBVIOUSLY I had to undo it". That's massively disrespectful to RTD's enitre era.

Reply

wheatear November 25 2013, 23:25:45 UTC
Where did he say that? The episode has all three Doctors willing to commit genocide on their own people so that's just not how it actually happened at all.

Reply

_thirty2flavors November 25 2013, 23:39:35 UTC
"He wouldn’t. He wouldn’t. I don’t care what’s at stake, he’s not going to do it. So that was the story - of course he never did that. He couldn’t have. He’s the Doctor, he’s the man who doesn’t do that. He’s defined by the fact that he doesn’t do that. Whatever the cost, he will find another way. So it had to be the story of what really happened that he’s forgotten.”

Oop forgot the source.

Reply

rosaxx50 November 26 2013, 06:46:43 UTC
And then the respect I'd brief gained for Moffat during the episode died once again. THE AUTHOR IS DEAD I INSIST, I DENY YOUR INTENTIONS AND REPLACE THEM WITH MY OWN.

Reply

wheatear November 26 2013, 23:04:36 UTC
Oh well. I'll go with rosaxx50, the author is dead. The episode itself was far better than that.

Reply

rosaxx50 November 26 2013, 06:45:24 UTC
ETA: Whoops replied to the wrong comment.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up